News, Analysis and Opinion for the Informed Boulder Resident
Friday February 24th 2017

Support the Blue Line

Subscribe to the Blue Line

That's what she said

city council transportation energy municipalization xcel housing april fools urban planning bicycles climate action density election 2011 boulder county open space affordable housing agriculture renewables CU local food election 2013 jefferson parkway youth climate change pedestrian development election 2015 preservation Rocky Flats BVSD immigration recreation mountain bikes GMOs transit farming boards and commissions decarbonization plan boulder urban design fracking fires wildlife colorado politics architecture smart regs downtown new era colorado journalism plutonium homeless transit village radioactive waste commuting natural gas ghgs parking rental height limits planning board april fools 2015 historic preservation energy efficiency coal diversity Neighborhoods historic district students walkability North Boulder gardens education land use arts population growth growth election 2010 solar bus University Hill taxes water supply election 2012 water quality RTD library zoning nutrition groundwater bike lane safety affairs of the heart april fools 2016 organic electric utility mayor planning reserve election zero waste politics county commissioners longmont hogan-pancost hazardous waste ballot obama golden right-sizing transportation master plan flood electric vehicle Mapleton solar panels climate smart loan recycling comprehensive plan sprawl PV colorado legislature bears diagonal plaza blue line wetlands epa conservation easement pesticide food congestion street design drought election 2016 boulder junction inequality road diet bus rapid transit renewable energy ken wilson automobile children community cycles daily camera ecocycle Newlands campaign finance sam weaver league of women voters PUC community david miller climate change deniers wind power boulder bob bellemare boulder creek bsec contamination modernism john tayer crime lisa morzel suzanne jones kevin hotaling tim plass Whittier mlk EV green points BVCP technology Orchard Grove arizona civil rights west tsa flood mitigation marijuana public spaces

Going Down With the Xcel Ship


By

As the Boulder City Council considers the merits of municipalization and Boulder’s carbon reduction goals, it is essential to recognize that there are opportunities and risks with EITHER path going forward—establishing a muni or establishing a deal with Xcel.

By Frederick Whymper - From page 293 of the 1887 book The Sea: its stirring story of adventure, peril & heroism., Volume 2. Found via project Gutenberg here [1]., Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=41134597

By Frederick Whymper – Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=41134597

With all of Xcel’s major coal suppliers now in Chapter 11 bankruptcy, with Xcel’s failure to consider even the possibility that the US coal industry won’t rebound, and with the potential for utility grid defection and load defection as documented by The Rocky Mountain Institute, there is clearly a risk with the Xcel path of tying Boulder to a sinking ship.  Grid defection occurs when consumers have other options for power that don’t make them dependent on the grid.  Load defection occurs when consumers shift their energy load from utility-delivered electricity to their own self-generated and stored power.

The risks of grid and load defection are underscored by the recent report from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratories showing the continuation of dramatic declines in the prices for wind and solar electricity.

For solar, the 2014 average contract price was 5¢ per kWh. For 2015, 4¢ per kWh, a 20% reduction.

For wind, the 2014 average contract price was 2.4¢ per kWh. For 2015, 2.0¢ per kWh, a 16% reduction.

Although Xcel has made some advances in acquiring wind and solar, it still has major commitments to coal, and may not be agile enough to keep up with changing market conditions.  Xcel’s customers will be on the hook for costs from rising fossil prices and/or the collapse of the fuel supply.  A municipal utility, owning no generation assets itself, and able to lock-in long term low prices with power purchase agreements of renewable energy, would be insulated from those risks.

Rate this article: 1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (4 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
Loading...

What do you think? Leave a comment!

You must be logged in to post a comment.